Veganism for the Poor?

1 t5x1R-UwSwMt1tXoI6_0UA

There is a peculiar tendency, especially among social justice warriors who advocate intersectionality, to reply to anybody promoting a vegan lifestyle with some variation of “but poor people can’t be vegan.” This is almost inevitable during any debate on the topic of veganism, and it occurs so frequently and reliably such that it deserves a closer look. I believe that this sort of statement serves several purposes, including: (1) to derail the conversation; (2) to provide a strawman argument against veganism; (3) to signal one’s virtuosity; and (4) to perpetuate the trope that vegans are assholes.

Before going into each of these, I would first like to say that nobody is in any position to tell poor people what to eat. Adhering to any special diet — including (or especially) veganism — requires the privilege of choice; poor people have little to no say in what they eat. While many people overestimate the extra expense and inconvenience necessary to be vegan, no one has a right to tell poor people what to eat.

You’d be hard pressed to find any vegans that disagree with this. Judging by the number of times the “poor people can’t be vegan” statement is uttered, you’d be forgiven for thinking that vegans are hellbent on guilting every last person into giving up animal products, no matter their income. In reality, vegans are generally understanding people who acknowledge the struggles of the poor and encourage, recognize, and congratulate any effort people make to reduce their consumption of animal products.

Indeed, the invocation of “poor people can’t be vegan” is seldom in response to anything related to poverty. This statement functions as a means to take the focus off of the person saying it (who seems to never make the claim that they are poor themselves) and onto the person who is advocating veganism. Effectively, it derails the conversation from a discussion of the merits of veganism (among people generally able to abstain from animal products without much inconvenience) to an accusation of disdain for the poor.

Similarly, it is a strawman argument. Rarely is the “poor people can’t be vegan” response targeted at somebody who said anything about the poor. It is used to deflect from the topic at hand — or, more accurately, to characterize vegans or veganism as something they are not, in order that they may be swiftly dismissed without any semblance of rational consideration of their arguments. People who engage in this dishonest rhetoric who are not poor are “appropriating” the struggles of the poor to alleviate feelings of guilt that result from participating in the suffering caused by animal agriculture.

Which brings us to virtue signaling. Intersectionality encourages activists to seek out anything that can conceivably be argued to be a form of systemic oppression, and to be as loud as possible about it. Finding a new cause — the more obscure the better — is a trophy hunt, and the discoverer is rewarded with praise for speaking out for the “victims.” Similarly, stating one’s alliance with victims of the intersections of disadvantage functions as a means to both receive praise and to signal one’s virtuosity. Therefore, “poor people can’t be vegan” serves the purpose of not only derailing the conversation and providing a strawman argument against veganism, but also of letting everyone know that the person who made the statement is a Good Person who stands in solidarity with the oppressed. It is the social justice warrior equivalent of commenting “first” on a shitty YouTube video.

Lastly, it is meant to perpetuate the stereotype that vegans are rude by implying that they are hassling the poor about going vegan. As already stated, this is not true, as it is rarely a response to somebody who said anything about poverty, and vegans are generally understanding people who are empathetic toward the poor and are happy to see any reduction in the exploitation of animals. By bringing up poverty, the person who says “poor people can’t be vegan” is effectively putting words in the mouth of the person to whom they are responding. This way, veganism can be dismissed as an oppressive, classist, philosophy with little to no self-awareness.

Who needs rational debate when you’ve decided your interlocutors are assholes?

2 thoughts on “Veganism for the Poor?

  1. I disagree with the simplicity of your statement that “no one has the right to tell poor people what to eat.” This has to be broken down into a few layers.

    1. Are these people that we are feeding on our dime at, for example, a soup kitchen? If yes, we absolutely have the right to decide what the serve and they can’t take it or leave eat. If they insist on meat, well, farewell. Tried to be nice, and they decided to be assholes.

    2. If these are poor people who are buying their own food, then I generally hold them to the same standard I hold everyone else. But what if they can’t afford vegan food? This is a fake argument. Show me the nutrition content of their non-vegan shopping cart and the dollar total, and I am confident I can fill a vegan cart with the same nutritional value for the same price. You would be surprised what beans and grains can do for you. (needless to say, fruit/vegetable nutrition is same cost in both carts so no excuse for the poor there). Still waiting for someone to take me up on this challenge.

    Now if you want to throw cheap fast food into the mix, again I introduce my nutrition/cost analysis. Cheap fast food fills you up and sneaks in protein but does little else. I can do the same with pasta and beans, for cheaper.

    So even getting past the obvious straw man purpose of the “poor people” argument, I will confront the argument on the merits as applied to actual poor people, and still win.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s